Is a credit card annual fee worth paying?

A fee is worth paying only when the rewards and benefits you will really use are worth more than the fee, after the extra GST banks add. The mistake most people make is counting benefits they will never use.

The fee is not the whole cost

The annual fee a bank quotes is usually before GST. Banks add 18% GST on fees, so a ₹1,000 fee costs ₹1,180 on your statement. The joining fee, where there is one, carries GST too. When you compare cards, compare the amount that actually leaves your account.

A simple break-even

Take the card's annual fee with GST. Divide it by the rate the card returns on your spending. The answer is the yearly spending where the card starts to pay for itself. A card that returns 1.5% and costs ₹1,180 needs about ₹78,700 of spending a year, or roughly ₹6,600 a month, just to break even. Spend less than that and a free card with a lower rate beats it.

Do this with your own spending, not a hopeful figure. If you spend ₹30,000 a month on cards and the fee card only beats the free card above ₹60,000, the free card wins for you however attractive the brochure looks.

Fee waivers are conditional

Many banks waive the next year's fee if you spend a stated amount in the year. That can turn a fee card into a free card, but only if you were going to spend that much anyway. Chasing a waiver by spending more than you planned wastes money. Also check how the bank counts the spend, since some exclude the same categories that do not earn rewards, such as fuel or rent.

Milestone benefits, such as bonus points or vouchers at a spending level, work the same way. They are worth counting only for spending you would have done regardless.

Benefits that are really worth something

Lounge access, travel insurance, golf rounds, dining discounts and concierge services have a real value only if you use them. A useful test is to ask what you would pay for the benefit if you were buying it separately, and whether you did that in the last year. If you flew twice and the card gives eight lounge visits, six are worth nothing to you.

Count only the benefits you used last year or have a firm reason to use this year. Put a rupee value on each and add them to the rewards. If the total clears the fee with room to spare, the card is worth it. If it only clears the fee when you count everything optimistically, it is not.

When a free card is the better answer

For most people with modest spending, a good lifetime-free card with a decent base rate beats a fee card. Fee cards earn their keep when you spend a lot, when you travel enough to use the benefits, or when a single category you spend heavily in gets a rate no free card matches.

Where to look next

Common questions

Can I get the annual fee waived by asking?

Sometimes. Banks occasionally waive or reverse a fee for customers who spend steadily or who ask when they are about to close the card. It is never guaranteed, so do not count on it when comparing cards.

Does the annual fee have GST?

Yes. Fees and most charges on credit cards attract 18% GST, which is added on top of the quoted amount.

Should I keep paying a fee for a card I barely use?

Probably not. Compare what it returned last year against the fee. If it did not clear the fee, ask the bank to downgrade it to a free version before the fee is charged.

Written by SahiCard, independent and paid by no bank. General information, not financial advice.

Work out which card pays you the most · Best card guides

More guides